When the comment period on the proposed Head Start rule closed in October, we wrote about what happens next and promised to come back when there was news. There is no final rule yet. But we now have a clearer picture of what the government heard.
About 40,000 comments
According to K-12 Dive, about 40,100 comments were submitted on the proposal, which would replace most of Head Start's national program standards, including its limits on class sizes and teacher-to-child ratios. That is a very large response for a federal rule about early childhood programs.
Not every comment has been tallied by topic. One early review, by the news literacy group Press Audit and reported by EdSource, looked at about two-thirds of the comments and found that nearly 89 percent opposed the changes and about 5 percent supported them. That is one group's analysis of part of the record, not an official count.
Who weighed in
The comments came from every direction:
- Head Start programs. The National Head Start Association said it supports cutting unnecessary paperwork but that the proposal goes too far.
- Early childhood experts. The National Association for the Education of Young Children asked HHS to withdraw the rule, warning that it would remove "critical, evidence-based standards."
- States. Attorneys general from 23 states and the District of Columbia, led by California and New Mexico and joined by Kentucky's governor, filed a joint comment opposing the rule. They objected to dropping ratio limits, services for children with disabilities, transportation safety standards and parent committees. They also opposed an English-only instruction requirement and cutting the cap on administrative costs from 15 percent to 5 percent.
- Congress. Nearly 200 Democratic and independent members of Congress asked for the rule to be withdrawn, arguing that it would illegally weaken services the Head Start Act requires.
- Supporters. Many commenters agreed with the administration that some rules are duplicative and that local programs and families should have more say. HHS has said the changes would save $2.2 billion and could add 236,000 slots. At least one conservative think tank went further and argued that Head Start should be phased out.
What happens now
The agency has to consider these comments and answer the significant ones when it publishes a final rule. There is still no set date. It could finalize the proposal, change it, or let it sit. Civil rights groups, including the ACLU, have said they would seriously consider going to court if the final version looks like the proposal.
What families should know
- Nothing has changed in your child's classroom. Every Head Start program is still operating under the current standards.
- Your state's rules matter. If the national standards are cut, state child care licensing rules become the main floor for things like ratios and group sizes. Now is a good time to learn what yours say.
- Ask your program. Directors know how this would affect them. Ask what they would keep doing either way, especially for dual language learners, who are an asset to a classroom, and children with disabilities.
We'll read the final rule when it comes and explain what changed. Until then, the best thing to know is that the standards protecting your child today are still in place.